The paradox of prevention in medicine

Celebrated as a principle, but resisted in practice. A reflection on prevention in the real world. Myths and realities of a proposal more declaimed than concretized.

Introduction 

Why is prevention so difficult?
This is a daily question in medical practice and public health, as well as in those that formulate public policies. 

Prevention was very important to increase longevity to current levels. Fossil records suggest that people 25,000-40,000 years old survived on average until they were 25 years old. In the millennia before the beginning of the 20th century, life expectancy increased another 25 years, at a speed of no more than 1 year for every thousand years. Subsequently, in only 100 years, the life expectancy in the most developed countries increased another 25 years.
Only in the twentieth century the acceleration of economic growth, the best hygienic practices and the recognition of infectious diseases allowed better nutrition and better living conditions and the widespread administration of vaccines and antibiotics. The great infectious diseases that flourished in the slums of the newly industrialized nations were no longer so threatening.
In 2010, noncommunicable diseases caused two thirds of deaths worldwide. This epidemiological transition increased the importance of the prevention of chronic diseases. 

Preventive approaches differ from the traditional curative approach. When the patient seeks medical attention for his symptoms, the doctor's objective is to make the diagnosis, to know the pathology that causes the disease and to identify the optimal treatment for that patient. For attention and cure it is not important to know how many others in the population experience a similar illness. 

Preventive medicine and healing medicine
Prevention reverses the usual order of medical thinking: it often begins at the demographic level and then transfers the information to each patient.
  • The preventive medicine is not focused on the pathology of the disease but at risk.
     
  • In curative medicine , the goal is for patients to recover their previous state of good health.
     
  • In prevention, as when we deal with hypertension or hypercholesterolemia in a population, the goal is for the entire population to change to a healthier level. 
     
  • While in curative medicine the professional responsibility is towards the patient, in preventive medicine, the center is at the level of the population. 
     
  • In curative medicine, the solutions are to prescribe medications, surgery, or other treatments. 
     
  • In prevention, there is much greater diversity of possibilities, from changes in behavior to altering social conditions, in addition to interventions such as vaccinations.
Obstacles to prevention
"The success of prevention is silent and invisible"
Success is invisible
This obstacle is fundamental and intrinsic to prevention. There is no way to document or demonstrate that a person's preventive efforts improved their health. It can only be presumed that the permanent effort to maintain a healthy diet, avoid sedentary lifestyle and smoking contributed to avoid a myocardial infarction. On the other hand, it is possible that this person had been among hypertensive and sedentary smokers who do not suffer a heart attack.
Statisticians and scientists can list the results that occur, such as the number of myocardial infarctions and the number of deaths. But when prevention is successful, it creates an absence of events: when it works, the success of prevention is silent and invisible. 

Invisibility produces problems.
Due to the invisible success, some people may believe that vaccines are no longer necessary. Some diseases, such as whooping cough or measles, may seem far away, and claims about the risks of vaccination may sound more threatening, although there is no reliable evidence to support them. When a sufficient number of people are left to vaccinate, as happened in the United Kingdom and Japan, outbreaks occur. Deaths from recent outbreaks of whooping cough in California could have been avoided. When vaccination rates decrease, diseases may reappear, but when vaccines are used, their success is invisible. 

Absence of spectacularity

Certain types of healing interventions are spectacular. When a child can survive thanks to a liver transplant, the child, family and medical team are excited and excited. But does anyone think of the other child, the one who was a donor, who died in an accident because the parents did not put him in the right seat? The tragedy that could have been prevented is not taken into account.
"Statistical lives have little emotional effect"
Statistical Lives Statistical
lives have little emotional effect. Statistics can estimate the number of lives saved by prevention, even if people can not be identified. A few years ago a little girl got trapped in a well in Texas. The media coverage was impressive and when after two days the firefighters could release it, they were relieved. However there are many children with lives limited by poverty and family conditions that do not receive continuous coverage because their circumstances are not spectacular as those of the little girl in the well. 

Personal stories move. It is difficult, on the other hand, to be moved by a statistic. 

Remote results
People in general when they want something, they want it immediately. Prevention often means doing something every day and the reward is not only statistical and invisible, but also remote. Most people prefer tangible rewards here and now. 

The benefits come to who pays for prevention
Whoever pays for prevention is often not the one who reaps the rewards due to the possible reduction in the burden of disease. 

From the commercial point of view, supporting prevention is not a very smart proposal. Let's suppose that the directory of a hospital has the opportunity to launch a program that helps treat diabetes in the population. In this hypothetical situation, the hospital could hire a group of health workers led by a nursing team to work in the community to educate and motivate patients with diabetes. Patients measure their glycemia at home and the nurses control them by e-mail. Each time a patient has hyperglycaemia, a nurse visits him to make sure he meets the treatment. As a result, it is predicted that hospitalizations could be halved and patients would feel better. The average cost would be only US $ 1500 per patient per year, paid by the hospital, where the number of bed days per patient would also decrease due to the 50% decrease in hospitalizations of patients with diabetes. This means that the hospital supports the added costs of this program while losing income from patients. The board of directors of the hospital should ask if they were prepared to make this investment. 

Too often, the benefits of prevention do not reach the person who pays for it.
"Prevention is not always the right thing or the smartest"
Changing or contradictory preventive recommendations
During the conversations for the reform of the health system in Washington, there was a debate about recommendations for mammography. After examining the data showing how often mammography leads to false positives, other unnecessary examinations and biopsies, the US Preventive Services Task Forcerecommended that instead of systematically indicating mammography for all women aged 40-50 years, in that age group women and their doctors had to decide whether to obtain it or not based on the risk of each. Younger women should continue with regular mammograms only if they had a family history.
Recent evidence suggests that confidence in mammography did not changefollowing the recommendations of the experts. However, these recommendations emphasize that prevention, although it is the most successful strategy in health, is not always the right nor the most intelligent. In preventive screening, the value to the patient depends on the risk of illness, the frequency and consequences of the error and the ability to correctly detect and act accordingly.

For the public, the new recommendations on mammography seemed another example of changing and contradictory advice. Science progresses when it reexamines, refines and discards previous beliefs. The action should be based on what is considered true, but nevertheless this creates a weaker preventive message because there is no guarantee that the council will not change in the future. 

Persistent behavioral changes may be necessary Persistent behavioral
changes are difficult, but necessary to become aware of the benefits of prevention. It is not useful to control blood pressure only occasionally and then remember to take the medications. The difficult part of healthy behavior is to make healthy decisions day after day.

Prejudice against errors by action
Many people consider that there is a difference between the adverse consequences due to some action and those that derive from natural causes, even if they could have been prevented. Most do not feel the same about a death due to "natural causes" than about a death caused by their own actions. When it comes to prevention, most people regret mistakes more when acting than errors of omission.
Benjamin Franklin, who lost his 4-year-old son due to smallpox in 1763, warned about this difference: "For a long time I regretted bitterly and I still regret not having vaccinated him. I mention this for parents who do not vaccinate their children for assuming that they would never forgive themselves if their child died of the vaccine; my example shows that remorse can be the same on one side or the other and therefore the one that is safest must be chosen. " 

The acceptance of avoidable damage as normal
Too often, many people accept avoidable damage as normal. News reports usually report another murder and another fatal car crash. These unfortunate events happen, but many could be avoided. Almost everyone used to think that smoking was normal, but at the present time smoking in general is socially unacceptable. Thinking that things are normal when they are avoidable is a psychological obstacle to implementing prevention strategies. 

They can make safer cars and build safer roads. Sweden adopted a goal called Vision Zero to eliminate road deaths and some US jurisdictions are doing the same. 

Double standards in the evaluation of prevention in relation to treatment
Whenever a new treatment for a certain disease is presented, the main question is whether it is useful. People want to know if the possibility of survival is greater with the new treatment or without it and perhaps at what cost.
For prevention, the question is formulated from a different perspective: preventive intervention must not only be effective and profitable, but also save on resources. The money that society saves for the use of a vaccine must exceed the cost of the vaccine. Preventive interventions should produce net savings, while therapeutic interventions require only better value. There is a double standard for judging the merits of preventive interventions in relation to therapeutic interventions. 

Commercial conflicts of interest
This is an obvious obstacle to prevention. For example, how can tobacco companies promote their products indifferent to the overwhelming data set about the harmful effects of tobacco smoke?

Strong commercial interests can distort and cause problems, even when those interests promote an effective preventive - as in the controversy over the HPV vaccine. Commercial interests can act against prevention directly or indirectly. However, they could be beneficial if the incentives could be realigned in such a way that more profits and better health are produced through the same actions. 

Conflicts with personal, religious and cultural beliefs
Preventive strategies are sometimes contrary to deeply held religious or personal beliefs. Some religious leaders teach that it is immoral to use condoms, even to prevent the spread of a sexually transmitted disease that can be deadly. Some believe in healing by faith and abjure modern medicine. When preventive actions are contrary to very deep convictions, everything is much more difficult.
Strategies to overcome obstacles to prevention
The following are some ways to overcome the barriers to successful prevention. 

Economic
compensation for prevention Physicians must be paid for the preventive actions they take. It was found that this was successful with vaccines in children. It is necessary to apply it to other topics - food counseling, physiotherapy and health advice, among others - in order to reward doctors and health institutions for keeping their patients healthy. 

Reduce the costs of preventionNot only the doctor needs incentives, but these should also be procured for the population. In the current culture that demands both better value and money saving from prevention, individuals and families will be more likely to adopt preventive measures if they receive some economic reward. This is not a novel idea: Mexico has for years been a program based on this model. Currently associated with the health policy called Seguro Popular, the program encourages low-income families with cash rewards to control their health, receive vaccines and adopt other preventive measures. 

Involve employers
Adults spend much of their time at work and therefore employers have significant opportunities to influence the health of the population. Instead of considering health policies as a benefit provided by work, employers could consider prevention as an investment and a positive contribution to the company's success. 

A study compared Johnson & Johnson, which has a health promotion program in the workplace for more than 30 years with other equally large companies based on the costs of health care and employee health risks. Not only were Johnson & Johnson employees found to be healthier, with significantly lower rates of obesity, high blood pressure and high cholesterol, smoking and physical inactivity, but the health prevention program paid off to the company at lower rates. of absenteeism and reduction of very expensive interventions.
Programs that encourage employees to take better care of their health can be very useful in improving the health of the population. 

Reengineering to reduce the need for individual action
Engineering, when used for public health and prevention needs, can increase health and safety. Airbags in cars and anti-lock braking systems helped minimize avoidable risk. In another step forward, a breathalyzer screen to start the car could reduce the number of people driving in a drunken state. On another front, designing and manufacturing vaccines from a single dose instead of multiple doses would make the vaccine more convenient. Engineering can help in many ways to facilitate prevention and health institutions would benefit from the participation of engineers in curative and preventive medicine. 

Use policies that facilitate the right options
There are policies to support prevention in many states, but they are not uniform throughout the United States. Laws and regulations on helmets for cyclists, water fluoridation, for example, can be very useful for better health. Public policies to reduce salt consumption, eliminate trans fats in food products and reduce sugar in the diet could reduce the risk of hypertension, cardiovascular disease and diabetes throughout the population.
In preventive policies, the decision of the mayor of New York to ban smoking in public places, along with the considerable tax increase for cigarettes reduced smoking rates by 11.2% in the first 5 years. Those responsible for formulating public policies can do much to facilitate prevention. 

Use of multimedia to educate, reformulate and obtain positive changesIt will be useful to make prevention easier, cheaper and more convenient. It is equally important that doctors explain prevention better to the entire population. It should be disclosed that preventable health risks are truly avoidable and establish a culture that celebrates healthy daily choices. It is necessary to reformulate prevention: the commission and omission costs must be considered equal, the standards to measure the value of prevention and treatment must be comparable and the statistics that show the success of prevention must be humanized.

The traditional media - newspapers and magazines, radio and television - and the new social networks of the Internet can be mobilized in this effort, together with the entertainment industry. The unconventional use of communication tools can give positive results. For example, the US Centers for Epidemiology (CDC) recently used a story about the upcoming zombie invasion to inform the public about pandemic preparedness with remarkable effectiveness.

A well-known specialist in communication and advertising in the US pointed out that the advertising of a product should never try to teach something totally new, but something that people already feel or believe, but have not yet expressed. Advertisers of commercial products are successful when they can match people's beliefs and desires and make the product be used as part of a daily habit.
Perhaps those in the field of health and prevention can also ask themselves what the public already thinks and how those wishes and beliefs can be ascertained to promote prevention. What would be the effective ways to know and disseminate something that people already care about and transform it into a healthy habit? It is necessary to connect prevention with what people already value in order to transform it into a daily reality.
Conclusion
Health workers should not expect a sudden transformation; Preventive messages must be repeated by all means of communication and entertainment so that over time they are consolidated as cultural norms.
In order to succeed, the sustained effort of individuals and families in their daily lives will be necessary; of doctors, nurses, pharmacists and other health professionals; of celebrities from the world of culture, entertainment and sports; of employees and insurers; of political, civic and business leaders and philanthropists. It is worth investing in prevention in order to enable a healthier future for all.
Share:

No comments:

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Labels

Recent Posts

Label Cloud